Mrs. Kelder's Cakes Manlius, NY
Made to order

Custom cakes, cupcakes and cookies, by inquiry

Birthdays, weddings, showers and milestones, designed around your colors, flavors and theme. Everything we make is fresh, so we can only accept a limited amount of custom work each week. Please choose an open date below and tell me about your celebration. We can then determine if we are able to create your order.

Start an Inquiry
A little custom magic

Cakes we have loved making

A peek at what is possible. Bring your idea or an inspiration photo and we will make it yours.

A character birthday sheet cake An elegant ivory and gold tiered cake A bright first birthday cake with a smash cake An elegant pink and gold tiered celebration cake A teal two tier cake with a custom topper A playful seasonal themed cake A pink tiered birthday cake with a doll topper A colorful celebration cake
Build your cake

Mix and match your flavors

Pick a cake, a filling and a frosting, and we will make it yours. Not sure where to start? I am happy to help you choose.

Cake

  • Chocolate
  • Vanilla
  • Confetti
  • Strawberry
  • Cinnamon Roll
  • Cookie Dough
  • Lemon
  • Red Velvet
  • Mint Chocolate
  • Carrot Cake
  • Pumpkin Spice*
  • Lemon Blueberry*
  • Apple Spice*
  • Cranberry Orange*

Filling

  • Strawberry
  • Lemon
  • Raspberry
  • Bavarian Cream
  • Chocolate Bavarian Cream
  • Marshmallow Creme
  • Salted Caramel
  • Nutella
  • Apple*
  • Blueberry*
  • Peach*

Frosting

  • Vanilla
  • Caramel
  • Chocolate
  • Chocolate Raspberry
  • Chocolate Hazelnut
  • Mocha
  • Cream Cheese
  • Raspberry Cream Cheese
  • Peanut Butter

Any frosting can also be used as a filling.

*  seasonal availability
Custom orders

Start a custom inquiry

Choose what you would like, pick an open date, and tell me about your celebration. Every request comes in organized, so we skip the back-and-forth and get straight to the fun part.

Check a date

Choose at least one item in the form first. The calendar only shows open dates once you do. Pickups are Tuesday through Saturday, and I need at least 24 hours' notice.

Month
Open Your pick Not available

Choose at least one item in the form, and your open dates will appear here.

Still not seeing the date you want? That item is not available that day. Try another date, or call the shop at (315) 692-2128.

Start here: choose at least one item, and the calendar will show the dates open for it.

Picking it up

Roughly when you would like to collect it. Not a promise yet, I will confirm the time when I reply.

Where is it going?

Local delivery is quoted separately depending on the distance and the day. I will confirm the time and the cost before anything is charged.

About the cake

The full list to mix and match is right above this form. Not sure? Say so and I will help you pick.

About the smash cake

About the cookie cake

Cookie cakes only need the writing and your colors, so 24 hours' notice is usually plenty.

About the cupcakes

Happy to send a mix of whatever is freshest that morning if you would rather leave it to me.

About the cookies

Classics are chocolate chip, brownie, oatmeal raisin and snickerdoodle.

About the decorated set

Decorated sets are hand-piped one at a time, so these need the most lead time of anything I make. Send an inspiration photo with your reply if you have one.

Up to 4 pictures of cakes you love. They come through with your inquiry, so I can see what you are picturing.

Please check your spam or junk folder for our reply, and add orders@mail.mrskelderscakes.com and mrskelderscakes@gmail.com to your contacts so it lands in your inbox.

We read every request and reply personally, usually within a day or two. Please note that inquiries submitted Saturday through Monday will be responded to by the following Tuesday.

Thank you, your inquiry is in!

I have the details for your celebration and your requested date. I will be in touch personally, usually within a day or two, to talk flavors, sizing and a quote. Inquiries sent Saturday through Monday get a reply by the following Tuesday. Talk soon!